Caribbean Issues is a weekly sequence from Each day Kos. Hope you’ll be a part of us right here each Saturday. If you’re unfamiliar with the area, take a look at Caribbean Issues: Attending to know the nations of the Caribbean.
We consistently see the present resident of the Oval Workplace and his co-president Elon Musk saber-rattle and threaten invasions of our neighbors—all with the energetic help of media sycophants who name themselves “journalists.” It brings to thoughts the yellow journalism that helped spark the Spanish-American Warfare, simply to promote newspapers. it looks like we’re watching historical past repeat itself.
Saturday marks the anniversary of the sinking of the usMaine in Havana Harbor on Feb. 15, 1898, which led to 266 fatalities. The Maine’s demise turned the rationale to propel us into the Spanish-American Warfare.
As Malea Walker defined in the Library of Congress weblog on Feb. 6, improved printing presses and the brand new Linotype machine led to an enormous surge in newspaper manufacturing within the Eighteen Nineties—and each outlet wished to get as many readers as attainable.
Two publishers specifically are recognized for his or her rivalry at the moment: Joseph Pulitzer and William Randolph Hearst. Pulitzer bought the New York World in 1883 and was recognized for recruiting Nellie Bly and launching a colour Sunday complement in 1895. Hearst bought the New York Journal in 1895 which started the rivalry with Pulitzer, with Hearst even stealing away the favored Yellow Child cartoon from the World the next 12 months. As the 2 pushed for larger circulation numbers, the headlines turned greater and extra outrageous.
The time period “yellow journalism” started as a reference to Richard F. Outcault’s “Yellow Kid” cartoon. As a result of it was revealed in each The World and the New York Journal, “yellow kid journalism” or “yellow journalism” was a strategy to confer with the sensationalism that they have been each recognized for.
That context is essential to grasp what occurred after the usMaine sank.
… inside days of the explosion, newspapers have been blaming Spain. Proof was misreported and even fabricated, revealed with giant headlines and ugly pictures, stunning readers.
As soon as the blame was laid onto Spain, headlines in newspapers together with the New York Journal and the World started calling for motion. They even went so far as goading President William McKinley and the U.S. navy to attempt to drive a navy response.
And as M. Mallon wrote for City Fictionary in 2019, as soon as the official inquiry was launched and implied the usMaine was introduced down by “an external explosion,” all bets have been off for Hearst and Pulitzer.
The united statesS Maine Catastrophe: Yellow Journalism At Its Best
No matter proof, they extrapolated on the inquiry’s obscure conclusion in an effort to revenue from American hysteria. Solely 5 days after the incident, the World revealed the headline “The World’s Latest Discoveries Indicate The Maine Was Blown Up By A Submarine Mine,” whereas the New York Journal claimed “Crisis Is At Hand… Spanish Treachery.”
Although the U.S. authorities by no means particularly blamed Spain for the tragedy, this was essentially the most worthwhile conclusion for media. Audiences enthusiastically consumed this interpretation, growing the demand for retaliation.
[…]
Yellow journalism was so profitable as a result of it didn’t create an unfamiliar narrative, however somewhat buttressed its viewers’s present perceptions. The continued battle between Cuba and Spain had already captured the American consideration, so the general public was poised to obtain proof to help their in poor health will [towards Spain}. Because of this, Hearst and Pulitzer managed to deeply influence public opinion, despite the fact that they had fabricated information surrounding the culprit.
There was no Fox News, no X, no Facebook, and no Truth Social at the time, but hyping war to sell papers feels eerily like the “coverage for clicks” we see today.
In January, Meta announced it would no longer fact-check content. In response, Ethan Zuckerman, writing for the UK’s Prospect magazine, examined the critical role media played in driving the U.S. into the Spanish-American War—and the end result.
When the Spanish-American war ended later that year, the US took ownership of Puerto Rico, Guam and the Philippines. Hearst and Pulitzer were both fabulously wealthy and powerful. Other less successful newspaper owners warned of the dangers of using propaganda to mobilise public passions. Perhaps it’s worth considering that caution as we consider the alignments between a powerful new medium and a conservative populist movement.
[…]
Neither Hearst nor Pulitzer’s papers survived the twentieth century. A rival that did was the New York Occasions. Alarmed by the sensationalist propaganda Hearst and Pulitzer revealed main as much as the conflict in Cuba, the Occasions determined to tell apart its editorial coverage with a catchy slogan: “All the News That’s Fit to Print”. In the long term, serving a public with fact-based information was extra worthwhile than feeding populist passions.
We might need to maintain that in thoughts, simply in case Trump sends a battleship to drift off Greenland’s shore, looking for conflict with Denmark.
Within the wake of the temporary conflict, America declared itself Puerto Rico’s liberator and by no means left, as Caribbean Issues detailed in July.
The U.S. additionally took management of Guantanamo Bay. In 2003, the Cuba Solidarity Marketing campaign outlined that checkered historical past.
How the US stole Guantanamo Bay
The historical past of Guantanamo Bay is an ideal instance of US coverage in direction of Cuba for the reason that finish of the nineteenth century. In 1898, simply because the Cuban patriots’ independence military was about to attain victory after 30 years of armed wrestle towards the Spanish Crown, the US declared conflict on Spain after their warship, The Maine, was allegedly torpedoed by the Spanish. Later that 12 months, rule of Cuba was transferred from Madrid to Washington on the Treaty of Paris, the place no Cubans have been current, after US President McKinley had said “it wouldn’t be wise to recognise the independence of the Cuban Republic”.
Nevertheless, the Cuban wrestle for independence appeared prone to start once more, this time towards US rule and in 1901 the US launched the Platt Modification. This allowed the President handy over rule of the island to the Cuban individuals, however solely after a authorities and structure might be established that set out future relations between the 2 nations. A significant a part of the structure pressured the longer term Cuban authorities to lease a part of its territory for the institution of US naval stations. The consequence was the 1903 Everlasting Treaty, which determined {that a} piece of Cuban land was to be leased to the USA, and 100 years in the past the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base ceased to be part of Cuban territory.
The bottom was very unpopular with the Cuban individuals earlier than the US Navy had even moved in, main the Cuban authorities to write down a letter to Washington asking for any changeover ceremony to be saved to a minimal, as there had been protests towards the lease. However solely 9 years later, the US imposed one other settlement on Cuba, enlarging the dimensions of the US space to what it’s now, despite the fact that this lined an entry channel which had beforehand been agreed as a shared channel, to make sure ‘free trade.’
For extra on the Spanish-American Warfare and its aftermath, take a look at this cheeky, concise, animated historical past.
As we watch main newspapers and media shops buckle beneath the brand new Trump-Musk cabal, we should “remember the Maine” and the end result. The media’s earlier warmongering and extraction of help from the American public for each oppression and colonialism is part of our historical past we should always not ignore, lest it occur once more.
Be part of me within the feedback to debate, and for the weekly Caribbean Information Roundup.
