In abstract
Evan Low’s congressional marketing campaign obtained $60,000 in digital radio advertisements from a casino-owning Southern California tribe after the Democratic Assemblymember voted for a controversial playing invoice.
Assemblymember Evan Low represents a Silicon Valley district that would lose tens of thousands and thousands of {dollars} in native tax revenues if Gov. Gavin Newsom indicators a invoice that may enable casino-owning tribes to sue their opponents, non-public card rooms.
So it was stunning that Low, a Democrat who’s operating for Congress, twice voted this summer time for the measure and towards the cardboard rooms.
Now, one of many invoice’s greatest supporters, the Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians, has purchased $60,000 in radio advertisements supporting Low’s marketing campaign for a congressional race that’ll be determined by voters nearly 500 miles from the tribe’s reservation and its massive on line casino in San Diego County.
It’s unlawful for lawmakers to pledge a vote in change for a marketing campaign donation, and there’s no proof that occurred on this case. However Sean McMorris, a program supervisor for California Widespread Trigger, mentioned the Viejas advertisements look like political payback for Low’s votes within the Meeting.
“Even though there was probably no coordination between Evan Low and this (political action committee),” McMorris mentioned, “I can probably guarantee you they wouldn’t have spent that money if Assemblymember Low didn’t vote for their interests.”
Tauri Bigknife, the tribe’s legal professional normal, disputed that assertion.
“It’s not payback,” he mentioned. “It’s not buying a vote. It’s none of those things. There’s no there, there, OK? It’s supporting someone that we’ve had a longstanding relationship with.”
Bigknife famous that the tribe gave cash to Low’s congressional marketing campaign earlier than he forged his votes. The tribe’s donated not less than $9,900 to Low’s marketing campaign, based on Open Secrets and techniques.
Low’s vote additionally uncovered him to unfavourable promoting. The cardboard rooms paid for a billboard close to the San Jose airport slamming him for siding with tribes on the potential expense of tax income for the group he represents.
The invoice, which is awaiting Newsom’s signature or veto, would enable tribal governments to sue non-public card rooms over the tribes’ longstanding allegation that the playing halls are illegally providing card video games together with blackjack and pai gow poker.
Tribes say California voters gave them the unique rights to host the disputed video games. However as a result of they’re sovereign governments, the tribes lack authorized standing to sue the cardboard rooms.
The struggle over Senate Invoice 549 was one of the costly and contentious of the two-year legislative session that concluded final week. A bipartisan coalition of lawmakers, a lot of them with massive tribal casinos of their districts, pushed for the measure, whereas a smaller group of lawmakers with card rooms of their districts opposed it.
It adopted a failed 2022 sports activities betting initiative that the tribes spent thousands and thousands of {dollars} to sponsor and that included the same provision that may have let the tribes sue.
As they sought to win over lawmakers, the opposing playing pursuits donated not less than $4.3 million to the 120 members of the Legislature since January 2023, based on the Digital Democracy database. The tribes had been the larger marketing campaign spenders. That included giving $92,000 within the weeks main up to a crucial July vote to members of an obscure Meeting committee that regulates playing.
Low sits on the committee, which was the place he first voted towards the desires of the town of San Jose, one of many cities that stands to lose thousands and thousands of {dollars} in income ought to the tribes prevail of their struggle towards the cardboard rooms.
Low’s campaigns obtained not less than $18,100 from tribes and $12,000 from card rooms since 2023, although a full accounting of any extra playing donations Low could have obtained to his congressional account since July gained’t be obtainable till October.
Low is operating towards former San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo, a fellow Democrat, in a contentious race for the congressional seat at present held by retiring U.S. Rep. Anna Eshoo.
“We’re not surprised that Evan voted to harm his constituents in return for financial support, because he has a pattern of doing exactly that,” Liccardo’s marketing campaign mentioned in an emailed assertion. Liccardo’s marketing campaign accused Low of additionally accepting lots of of hundreds of {dollars} in marketing campaign donations from landlords and oil and energy firms after voting of their favor.
Be taught extra about legislators talked about on this story.
Low marketing campaign spokesman Nathan Click on mentioned in an e mail that the advertisements from the Viejas tribe had been an impartial expenditure that wasn’t related to Low’s congressional marketing campaign.
“On this and all other issues,” Click on mentioned, “Assemblymember Low is singularly focused on helping Californians and legislating in the best interest of his district and the state.”
Playing dispute threatens California cities
The Viejas tribe purchased the digital radio advertisements on Aug. 8, based on a submitting with the Federal Election Fee.
The advert purchase got here lower than a month after Low forged a key vote to advance Senate Invoice 549 from the Meeting Governmental Group Committee. The measure wanted 12 “aye” votes from the 22 members of the committee to move. It had 15. Low joined a few lawmakers who forged votes in favor of the invoice regardless of having card rooms of their districts.
Final week, the measure handed the Senate and the Meeting with Low voting for it a second time.
Card rooms, cities throughout the state and the cities’ worker unions oppose the invoice.
San Jose, in Low’s district, is the most important metropolis in opposition. San Jose Metropolis Councilmember Sergio Jimenez informed Low’s committee in July that the town receives $30 million every year from card rooms, sufficient to fund 150 law enforcement officials or 133 firefighters. Jimenez mentioned that cash’s in jeopardy if the tribes find yourself prevailing in court docket.
Low voted for the invoice regardless of noting within the committee listening to that he had considerations “about the potential for the loss of revenue and also the loss of jobs.”
Card rooms assault Low
The radio advert calls Low “a trailblazer,” and “a fearless advocate” who has been “standing strong against discrimination and hate.”
“Evan has been a powerful voice fighting to make the streets and neighborhoods of San Jose safe for you and your family,” the advert says, noting that the Viejas tribe paid for it.
In its federal marketing campaign submitting, the tribe mentioned it paid $60,000 to ALZA MethodsSacramento public relations agency, to supply the advert. Its president, Roger Salazar, declined to say on what stations the advertisements had been operating or present different info.
Low, in the meantime, additionally was hit with unfavourable promoting following his vote on the playing invoice. Late final month, the cardboard room-funded Californians to Defend Metropolis Companies and Native Jobs erected a billboard on Freeway 101 close to the San Jose Worldwide Airport.
“Ask Evan Low why he voted to cut public safety funding, kill over 32,000 jobs (and) hurt small businesses,” the billboard reads, urging voters to name his Meeting workplace and demand he vote towards the playing measure when it was thought of on the Meeting flooring final week. The billboard makes no point out of Low’s congressional marketing campaign.
The billboard is deceptive.
There’s no assure the tribes will prevail in the event that they’re allowed to sue card rooms ought to Newsom signal the invoice. A decide may aspect with the cardboard rooms. The playing halls have lengthy argued that their card video games are authorized, and that state regulators have signed off on their enterprise mannequin.
Bigknife, the Viejas legal professional normal, mentioned the billboard message was an instance of why his tribe felt it was necessary to help Low and can proceed to take action in his race for Congress.
“They attacked him with false representations that were absolutely untrue in an effort, obviously, to demean his character and demean whether he cares about his community and to … undercut what he’s trying to do in running for Congress,” Bigknife mentioned.
In an announcement, Becky Warren, spokesperson for the California Gaming Affiliation, representing card rooms, didn’t deal with Low’s vote straight or the billboard.
“We are disappointed in legislators who voted for SB 549 and against the thousands of cardroom employees who are living and working in their communities,” she mentioned. “By voting for SB 549, they also cast a vote against their cities and the essential services residents rely on. This is why SB 549 was opposed by public employee unions, firefighters, cities and cardrooms.”
Hans Poschman and Thomas Gerrity, members of the CalMatters Digital Democracy crew, contributed to this story.
